Skip to main content
news

Re: Republicanism still an ...

David Flood
SubjectRe: Republicanism still an offence in England? (wasRe: Queen mother (of
FromDavid Flood
Date2002-04-17 18:39 (2002-04-17 17:39)
Message-ID<a9kbil$3q17c$2@ID-121201.news.dfncis.de>
Client
Newsgroupsalt.fan.tolkien
Followspaulh
Followupspaulh (1h & 4m) > David Flood
Jette Goldie (3h & 41m)

"paulh" <paulh@fahncahn.com>wrote in message news:e98rbucq4mthqb0qag38r7nos46i4d1g8r@4ax.com...

paulh
On 17 Apr 2002 15:48:58 GMT, mcresq@aol.com (Russ) wrote:

Russ
Actually, my rough figures very much overstated the IRA's imact on

civilians.

Here are the actual figures from the CAIN website:

A total of 1706 deaths are attributed to the IRA. Of that 1011 (or 60%)

were

British Security; 516 (or 30%) were civilians; 7 were Irish security; 32

were

Loyalist paramilitary; and 140 were Republican paramilitary (their own

and

others).

Let's compare the IRA's record with other groupings:

British Security (i.e. RUC, British Army, UDR, etc.) are credited with

363

death of which 192 (or 53%) were civilians.

And Loyalist paramilitaries are credited with 991 death of which 864 (a whopping 87% were civilians).

Not only was the IRA much more discriminating than the Loyalist

paramilitaries,

there were much mroe discriminating that British security services.

Quite frankly, IMO a force for which overall 70% of it's 'victims' were

other

combatants cannot be termed a terrorist force.

paulh
What utter rubbish. Can you show me anywhere credible, other than in your opinion, where terrorist forces are defined as those which only kill X% or

more

of 'civilians' vs combatants.. SO what ratio needs to be aspired to for

THIS

then? Perhaps if the Loyalist Paramilitaries kill more 'combatants' then

you'll

be happy to take them off the list of 'Terrorists'.. What a pathetic excuse to justify terrorism..

I guess it depends greatly on your personal point of view - who you consider guerillas/revolutionaries/freedom fighters, and who terrorists.

D.

paulh (1h & 4m) > David Flood
Jette Goldie (3h & 41m)