Skip to main content
news

Re: Republicanism still an ...

Russ
SubjectRe: Republicanism still an offence in England? (wasRe: Queen mother
FromRuss
Date2002-05-22 22:08 (2002-05-22 22:08)
Message-ID<20020522160855.14911.00000486@mb-cu.aol.com>
Client
Newsgroupsalt.fan.tolkien
FollowsBagronk the Happy Orc
FollowupsMorgil Blackhope (20h & 17m)
Bagronk the Happy Orc (22h & 55m)

In article <7lnneu0vj30p4jcqpldpg51vbuvvnttiah@4ax.com>, Bagronk the Happy Orc <vr-stefanien@arcor.de>writes:

Bagronk the Happy Orc
I found some words from mcresq@aol.com (Russ) in my phone cable...

I actually part company with Flame a bit here. I don't particularly like Christian fundamentalists and agree they are narrow-minded. On the other

hand,

they are not the bogeymen you make them out to be. You seem to have an especial dislike of Falwell, but to the best of my knowledge he never encouraged people to strap explosives on and walk into parties or to hijack airliners and slam them into buildings. Let's try to keep a little

perspective

here.

So why is Falwell more moderately than Osama, though they seem to share most arrtibutes (you mentioned fundamentalism and narrow-mindedness yourself)?

Your cause and effect dialectic is showing through.

<snip>

(Sorry if I seem to boil everything down to economics, but that's my Marxist pov, I can't help it).

Bollocks. There are and have been many poorer people than Arabs and the vast majority do not resort to terrorist violence.

Fundamentalism is bad on either side. But what it needs to stir that up from just a little annoying narrow-mindedness to a _deadly_ plane-hijacking fundamentalism is a) bad education up to illiterateness, b) a desperate economic situation,

The hijackers were all well educated and came from prosperous families. The planners of the outrage too were all well educated and came from prosperous families.

c) a mighty foe which you can envy.

I do not say fundamentalists are harmless if you keep them well-fed and rich, either. They basically stay the same anyway. But maybe they finally get a bit lazy. And they won't find successors when they prepare themselves for their last journey to whatever-they-imagine.

You mean like fundamentalists of the Marxist sort?

Russ