Skip to main content
news

Re: Republicanism still an ...

?jevind L?ng
SubjectRe: Republicanism still an offence in England? (wasRe: Queen mother
From?jevind L?ng
Date2002-05-15 23:02 (2002-05-15 23:02)
Message-ID<P1AE8.4755$iB4.13722@nntpserver.swip.net>
Client
Newsgroupsalt.fan.tolkien
FollowsPradera
FollowupsFlame of the West (1h & 14m) > ?jevind L?ng
chris cunningham (1d, 18h & 6m)

Pradera wrote:

[snip]

Pradera
Actually, the main reason Israelis insists on keeping West Bank is the strategical advantage this gives them. It's the '12 km' principle - without West Bank, Syrian tanks can get across Israel in 12 km from the border to the sea. That's what I heard, at least.

Does that explain why the Isaeli government keeps stealing land from Palestinians in order to found new Jewish settlements on them? The pace has *increased* since Sharon became PM.

?jevind L?ng
Anyway, you miss the point that the West Bank and Gaza do not belong to Israel and that it is illegal for them to keep them occupied.

Pradera
The problem is - they _won_ it in regular war, the war that wasn't even their fault, and in which they were the defensive side. So I don't know about illegality of that, at least from Israel's POV.

You don't becoem the rightful owner of an area because you conquered it in a war.

?jevind L?ng
Israel wants peace? Then let them leave the West Bank and Gaza. That

Pradera
*is*

?jevind L?ng
the first step.

Pradera
If that's just the first step, what's the second?

That they get peace with the Arabs. With the US protecting them, that should be fairly easy. At any rate, it would not be any harder than now, when they leave the Palstinians no hope at all. In fact, by a recent survey, two thirds of all Israelis share my opinion.

?jevind