Skip to main content
news

Re: Lenses and sharpening

Sandman
SubjectRe: Lenses and sharpening
FromSandman
Date2014-09-20 18:13 (2014-09-20 18:13)
Message-ID<slrnm1ract.qtr.mr@irc.sandman.net>
Client
Newsgroupsrec.photo.digital
Followsnospam

In article <200920141056424626%nospam@nospam.invalid>, nospam wrote:

nospam
iphoto makes a second copy of any changes.

Sandman
Just like Lightroom and Aperture.

nospam
not like lightroom or aperture at all.

Exactly like Lightroom and Aperture.

there's an original and a current.

True for Lightroom, Aperture and iPhoto.

it doesn't maintain a database of changes.

Sandman
Indeed it does.

nospam
it keeps a database of images, not an editing database.

Indeed it does. All your changes to the original file that is reflected in the current version are kept inside the database and can be reverted, or changed, at will.

I.e. import a RAW image, drag the saturation slider to the max, then the contrast slider to the max. Now, if you reset the saturation slider, you have removed that effect. Drag down the contrast slider and you have done the same with the contrast, and what you're seeing is the original image. Fully non-destructive and parametric editing.

Some actions, like red-eye and retouch, can't be progressively removed. I.e. you can't add contrast, saturation and then retouch the image, and then remove only your retouching. But that's because the UI in iPhoto is more simplistic than LR/Aperture, not because it's not non-destructive.

-- Sandman[.net]