Skip to main content
news

Re: What Is The Hardest Sce...

Patrick R. Judy
Google Google
SubjectRe: What Is The Hardest Scene For You To Visualize From The Books?
FromPatrick R. Judy
Date01/17/2002 01:12 (01/17/2002 01:12)
Message-ID<cGo18.57976$K36.18425973@news1.rdc1.va.home.com>
Client
Newsgroupsalt.fan.tolkien
FollowsDeadMike
DeadMike <someone@microsoft.com>wrote in message news:a23pci$5ai$1@newstoo.ericsson.se...

DeadMike
"Patrick R. Judy" <prjudy02@home.com>wrote in message news:He718.57558$K36.18248554@news1.rdc1.va.home.com...

Patrick R. Judy
The one thing from the books that I have a hard time visualizing is

DeadMike
the

Patrick R. Judy
part in The Hobbit where Bilbo, Gandalf and the Dwarves have to take

cover

because these giants are throwing boulders around. I've talked with

DeadMike
several

Patrick R. Judy
friends who have read the books as well and they said that scene is hard

DeadMike
to

Patrick R. Judy
fathom. What do you think would be the hardest scene from the books to be adapted visually without it coming off cheesy?

Patrick

DeadMike
Anything with Ents in it.

That and Shelob are more very good ones to point out. Like others have said, I hope that these are done well in the films. The Road To Isengard is going to be a real treat if done properly especially with Howard's score.

Patrick