Skip to main content
news

Re: What Is The Hardest Sce...

ESHAAS
SubjectRe: What Is The Hardest Scene For You To Visualize From The Books?
FromESHAAS
Date01/16/2002 05:50 (01/16/2002 05:50)
Message-ID<20020115235051.12091.00001660@mb-fs.aol.com>
Client
Newsgroupsalt.fan.tolkien
FollowsPatrick R. Judy
FollowupsTed Sallis (6h & 2m)

Patrick R. Judy
From: "Patrick R. Judy" What do you think would be the hardest scene from the books to be adapted visually without it coming off cheesy?

Patrick

Maybe the "Shelob" bit. It could be really great if done well, but let's hope it doesn't turn into a bunch of clunky, going-for-the-cheap-scare nonesense with a big silly spider-monster running around and none of the serious feeling of evil and revulsion that belongs in it. No "Arachnid Park", please!

Ted Sallis (6h & 2m)