Skip to main content
news

Re: Reading LotR and the ne...

?jevind L?ng
SubjectRe: Reading LotR and the newsgroups (was Re: Don't aspire to succeed - that right belongs to America
From?jevind L?ng
Date08/17/2004 23:47 (08/17/2004 23:47)
Message-ID<h0vUc.16628$qn2.2955@nntpserver.swip.net>
Client
Newsgroupsalt.fan.tolkien
FollowsAlison
FollowupsFlame of the West (10h & 12m) > ?jevind L?ng
Troels Forchhammer (13h & 47m)

"Alison" <news.poster@ntlworld.com>skrev i meddelandet news:5bh4i09rtc3a35ovdm8euaov9u4ptuif84@4ax.com...

[snip]

Alison
I always found the Sam and Frodo bits dreary as well. The first time I read the book, I wasn't really following the map, so I didn't realise where Minas Morgul was, and I certainly didn't follow all the wandering off in the wrong direction that goes on once they're past Cirith Ungol and into Mordor. On subsequent rereadings I sometimes used to skip most of Frodo and Sam's journey before meeting Faramir, and after leaving Cirith Ungol until they reach the mountain.

I've always suspected that the only reason for all that faffing about up to Udun and back is just to give F&S something to do while the captains of the West are marching to the Morannon, so that the climax of the quest comes just as they are about to lose the battle. They'd look a bit silly if F&S had just marched straight across Mordor in about 4 days and dropped the Ring in while the army was poncing about, blowing trumpets in Ithilien, wouldn't they?

[GRIN] I suspect you are right. I do wish Tolkien had been able to think up something to add more interest to the story there. Strange that there are only three chapters before "Of Herbs and Stewed Rabbit"; they 'feel* like a good deal more.

?jevind