Skip to main content
news

Re: Is RGB to Lab lossy? -...

PeterN
SubjectRe: Is RGB to Lab lossy? - was(Re: Lenses and sharpening)
FromPeterN
Date10/06/2014 00:25 (10/05/2014 18:25)
Message-ID<m0sggu22i4g@news6.newsguy.com>
Client
Newsgroupsrec.photo.digital
Followsnospam

On 10/5/2014 2:41 PM, nospam wrote:

nospam
In article <m0s2q9023s3@news1.newsguy.com>, PeterN <peter@verizon.net> wrote:

bottom line: rgb->lab->rgb offers no benefit (other than possibly contrived edge cases nobody will ever encounter).

PeterN
IOW you you have never worked in LAB

nospam
i have, and quite a bit. lab is useful for certain tasks, but photo editing isn't one of them.

PeterN
You have never noticed the ease of a color change in LAB, compared to making a similar color change in RGB.

YOu have never brought out color using LAB that could not easily be brought out in RGB.

nospam
nonsense.

you just don't know how to do it in rgb.

PeterN
The above are "edge cases."

nospam
if you say so.

Well explain exactly what you call edge cases. Should be easy for you, since you have experience workng in LAB..

-- PeterN